Halloween Most Likely To Game Printable: 32 Questions (Free)

Halloween “Most Likely To” Game Printable: 32 Spooky Questions (Free)

“Most Likely To” is the best low-effort party game ever invented. You read a question, everyone points at the person who fits best, and the roasting begins. I’ve played this at Halloween parties where half the guests didn’t know each other, and by question five everyone was laughing like old friends. Below are 32 Halloween-themed questions, written out in full — this page is your free printable. Print it, grab a pen for scorekeeping, and you’re the host with zero prep.

How to Play

• Print one sheet per player, or just have the host read from one copy while everyone votes aloud.
• Read each question. On the count of three, everyone points at the person they think is most likely to do it.
• The person with the most fingers pointed at them gets a point (or a sip, or a piece of candy — your call).
• Winner: the person with the most “most likely” votes at the end gets crowned the party’s Spooky Superstar.

House rule I swear by: nobody is allowed to vote for themselves. It keeps the game honest and twice as funny.

Want the polished party version? Our Halloween Most Likely To Game on Etsy comes as a designed voting sheet with a scorecard — but the full free question list is right here.

The 32 Questions

Costume & Party Chaos

1. Most likely to spend 3 hours on a costume and still change it last minute
2. Most likely to show up in the funniest costume
3. Most likely to show up in the scariest costume
4. Most likely to forget it was a costume party
5. Most likely to win the costume contest and act surprised
6. Most likely to take 100 selfies in their costume
7. Most likely to be asked “what ARE you supposed to be?” all night
8. Most likely to start the dance floor at the party

Spooky Situations

9. Most likely to survive a zombie apocalypse
10. Most likely to be the first one eaten in a horror movie
11. Most likely to get lost in a corn maze
12. Most likely to volunteer to go into the haunted house first
13. Most likely to scream at a jump scare and then laugh
14. Most likely to cry at a jump scare and then leave
15. Most likely to fall in love with a vampire
16. Most likely to befriend the ghost haunting the house
17. Most likely to investigate a strange noise instead of running
18. Most likely to say “let’s split up” in a haunted house

Candy & Mischief

19. Most likely to eat all the Halloween candy before trick-or-treaters arrive
20. Most likely to steal candy from their own kid’s bucket
21. Most likely to give out toothbrushes instead of candy
22. Most likely to trade their whole candy haul for one chocolate bar
23. Most likely to carve the best jack-o’-lantern
24. Most likely to set their pumpkin on fire (accidentally)
25. Most likely to keep their Halloween decorations up until Christmas
26. Most likely to start decorating for Halloween in September

Wildcard Round

27. Most likely to tell the best ghost story
28. Most likely to fall asleep during the scary movie
29. Most likely to host next year’s Halloween party
30. Most likely to dress their pet in a matching costume
31. Most likely to believe in ghosts (and have a story to prove it)
32. Most likely to be the life of every Halloween party

Score It Three Ways

The pointing is the fun part, but a little scoring keeps the energy up. Pick one:

• Candy bowl draft: each round’s “winner” (most votes) draws a piece of candy from the bowl. By the end, the biggest haul belongs to the group’s most notorious character — and everyone gets candy anyway.
• Point cards: give the host a stack of index cards. Each round’s winner gets a card with the question written on it. At the end, whoever holds the most cards is crowned Spooky Superstar — and has to give an acceptance speech.
• Team tally: split the room into two teams and count total votes per team. Losing team refills the snack bowl. It’s a beautiful system.

Make It Your Own

The best rounds always include a few custom questions about your actual group. Leave 3–4 blank lines at the bottom of your printout for write-ins like “most likely to [inside joke only this friend group understands].” Those always get the biggest reaction of the night.

Host Tips

• Read with energy. This game lives or dies on the host’s delivery — pause before the punchline, ham it up.
• Keep it kind. Funny roasts are the point, but skip anything that would genuinely embarrass someone. The host sets the tone.
• Mixed groups: if not everyone knows each other, do a 60-second intro round first so the voting means something.
• Prize: the Spooky Superstar gets first pick of the candy bowl or a silly paper crown. Cheap, memorable, perfect.

Want the Designed Most Likely To Pack?

Everything above is free to print straight from this page — print it and play tonight. If you’d rather have the styled version, our Halloween Most Likely To Game on Etsy includes the questions as a designed voting sheet with a matching scorecard and blank write-in lines — the polished, ready-to-print version of everything above. Happy voting!

🐶
Free Pet Guides

🐶 Love Dogs Too?

If your home includes a four-legged family member, our sister site Furveko is full of genuinely helpful dog guides — from picking the right winter coat to keeping them calm during fireworks. Written for real dog owners, by people who get it.

Visit Furveko.com →

🎁
Gift Ideas

🎉 Occasion Hunters — Gifts for Every Occasion

Never miss the perfect gift again — curated gift guides for Christmas, birthdays, weddings and every occasion in between.

Visit OccasionHunters.com →